Stocking Stuffers for Toddlers (Small, Cheap and Not Annoying)

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I only recommend things I truly believe in. Read my full disclosure.

A toddler stocking is a strange little puzzle. It has to be small. It can’t be a choking hazard. And it shouldn’t be fifteen pieces of plastic you’ll be stepping on in February.

Here’s what I’d put in one. I’ve been doing Christopher’s stocking since he was a baby (he’s seven now, so that’s a lot of stockings), and the toddler years were my favorite.

First, the boring safety part. For kids under 3, skip anything small enough to fit through a toilet paper tube, anything with button batteries, and anything with magnets that can come loose. Check the age label on every single item. I’m serious about this one.

The list

Bath toys. Cups that stack and pour, or the foam letters that stick to the wall. Cheap, and bath time becomes the new toy. mushie stacking cups work in the tub and out of it.

Board books. The tiny ones fit in a stocking perfectly. Lift-the-flap or touch-and-feel. That’s Not My Reindeer is a sweet touch-and-feel one for Christmas.

Chunky crayons or washable markers. The egg-shaped crayons are great for small hands, like My First Crayola Palm-Grasp Crayons.

Stickers. Big puffy ones for little fingers. Peeling them off is half the fun.

A toothbrush. I know. But a new one with their favorite character is weirdly exciting at this age.

Socks with grips. Useful, and they’ll actually wear them. Check for soft seams if your kid is picky about socks (mine was).

Snacks they already love. A pouch, some puffs. The stocking doesn’t need to be all toys.

A small flashlight with a big switch. We used ours for “bedtime adventures” all winter. Check that the battery cover screws shut.

A little fidget or squishy toy sized well above choking size.

What I’d skip

  • Candy for kids under 2. Not worth it.
  • Slime and play dough with tiny tubs. Your carpet will thank you.
  • Anything that needs to be assembled on Christmas morning before coffee.

If your toddler gets overwhelmed

A full stocking can be a lot. We started with three or four things in Christopher’s, and we let him take them out one at a time over the morning instead of all at once. Nobody needs to see every gift in ten minutes.

If you’re expecting this winter, our winter newborn essentials post has the cold-weather list.

What’s the best cheap stocking stuffer you’ve ever found? Leave it below so I can steal it.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *